Friday, April 20, 2007

Episode 10 - "Who Do You Most Trust?"

To Exile: Mookie

Immunity: Yau-man

Voted Out: Edguardo

Votes:
Boo, Cassandra, Earl, Stacy & Yau-man voted Edguardo
Alex, Edguardo & Mookie voted Cassandra
Dre voted Mookie

Who's Left: Alex, Boo, Cassandra, Dre, Earl, Mookie, Stacey & Yau-man

This one requires a bit of explanation. Cassandra, Earl and Yau-man pulled Boo and Stacey over to their camp with the plan of voting out Alex, while the Four Horsemen (Alex, Dre, Edguardo & Mookie) were going to vote Earl. Dre, trying to play both camps through Cassandra, was told by Earl and company to vote Alex. Dre told Alex and company what was happening so the decision was made for Mookie to give Alex the hidden immunity idol he carried. Dre then promptly told Earl's group what Mookie had done causing them to switch the target to Mookie. However, they later decided that Edguardo was a better idea. The five of them (Boo, Cassandra, Earl, Stacey & Yau-man) agreed on voting Edguardo, but also agreed that Dre was to be left out of the loop. In the meantime, Alex, Edguardo & Mookie decided to shift their vote to Cassandra in an attempt to split that alliance in two. When Dre heard about this plan, he was less than enthused.

HC's Take:

After a potentially enjoyable tribal council being sabotaged last week by a stupid twist, this week we get one of the most enjoyable tribal councils in the history of the series. Why, because events were allowed to play themselves out without wrenches being thrown in by the show's producers. Are you listening CBS?

Anyway, I thought I would split my comments into groups.

Cassandra, Earl & Yau-man: Perfectly played! Especially well done was how Cassandra winning the reward challenge was used to work on Boo and Stacey. Cassandra could not have picked a more perfect trio to accompany her. This is undoubtably thanks to her, and her allies, being given some time to think about their choices. At the vote, although the irony of voting out Mookie after he handed over immunity is delicious, Edguardo was the right call. If you can't get the number one guy, you hit number two.

Boo & Stacey: Right call by these two. Stacey is guaranteed final four with Earl and company with no such assurance from the four horseman, and Boo was the four horseman's original target after the merge, so you know his standing is even worse. Besides, Stacey's and Boo's biggest assets are each other. They need to stick together and look for any opportunities to improve their positions, and they can still easily come.

Alex & Edguardo: The reward challenge should have made it clear to you guys that you aren't half the players you think you are. Question: Who is the player you most trust? Most popular answer: Earl. Question: Who is the player that thinks they are controlling the game but isn't? Most popular answer: Alex. The writing was on the wall. Again, these guys showed they don't know how to create a stable alliance. Why would Stacey come your way when you are writing off Boo? Why would Dre work with you if you want to vote off Cassandra? Get a feel for the dynamics of the group and learn to work those dynamics in your favour.

Dre & Mookie: If Alex and Ed aren't half the players they think they are, these two aren't a tenth. While they were attempting to work everyone so that Alex didn't have all the power, they completely ignored the real threats: Earl and Yau-man. Now, it's just time to warm up your seats on the jury.

Now I know that the four horseman are going to whine about how they were screwed in this game, but let's be honest. They were handed a gift with Michelle last week and they failed to take advantage of it. Earl lost his number three in his alliance and was able to work to fill the hole. We know who deserves to be there in the end and who doesn't.

HC

2 comments:

AbstractMind said...

Up until now, I haven't exactly loved this season; but, this episode was a ton of fun to watch. I believe the show would be like this more often if they didn't keep trying to throw in all these plot twists to make it more "interesting." There is nothing more interesting than watching the players plot and scheme on their own without the decisions of Mark Burnett forcing them to make certain choices. I loved this episode.

Anonymous said...

You're a very smart man, HC. You called this last week. I'm impressed.

Not only was I impressed by the decision to vote Edgardo, (although slightly disappointed, because he was the most likable of the 'four horsemen') I was extremely impressed by Earl when he learned that Mookie had the idol.

"It's a turtle!" "Really!"

Not only a strong leader and strategizer, but a great actor too!

Alex's game is virtually over... although I think Dreamz may be the next to go. Earl/Yau rightly recognize that Dreamz isn't smart enough or devious enough to be trusted. He's too much of a wild card, and may be considered expendable now that Boo and Stacy are 4/5 in their alliance.